What can be said about Stirring’s eggnog that hasn’t already been said about getting hit in the face with a warm sack of diarrhea?
Actually, that’s a bad analogy. Stirring’s eggnog is like being told that you’re going to get the super-awesomest puppy that ever existed, when you instead end up with a dog that sexually assaults you.
Some back story: Mrs. ACW and I were doing some food shopping over the holidays and we opted to shop in a county with a higher-than-average tax bracket. The produce tends to be fresher, and the selection tends to be greater, and none of the cashiers are surly teenagers who lack the ability to add. The downside to all this is that the other shoppers have huge superiority complexes, entitlement issues, and feel that the world is owed to them, so they’ll frequently crash their carts into yours, fall down, and call triple A. Before you know what’s happening, you’ve been summoned to court to serve as a witness against yourself. Also, because these places tend to be whiter than a whitebread and mayonnaise sandwich, the “International Foods” aisle is typically Italian fare like spaghetti and pasta sauce. Occasionally you might find an old dusty box of taco shells that people keep buying to impress their house cleaner, and then returning the tacos after they fire the house cleaner. I imagine that most people in that area have owned those tacos for a day or two at least once. Suffice it to say, Mrs. ACW and I were not able to find the canned chipotle peppers on our list.
However, what they lack in diverse foods, they make up for in a new kind of eggnog. As we were wandering the aisles and gazing upon row after row of jarred peacock in truffle oil and ivory shavings, canned polar bear toes, and freeze-dried Irish babies, we came across the bottle of nog pictured above… and it cost $11. This makes it the most expensive nog purchase in my history of nogsumerism. Mrs. ACW looked at my joyful face, the price tag, and simply said, “That had better be some good fucking eggnog.” As you may have already surmised, it was not.
As soon as we got home I wanted to bust it open so I could try some, and since it was an eggnog cocktail concentrate, I would need to mix it with milk or liquor, sort of like the chai nog. So I mixed some up with some milk and took a sip… and it was weird. It tasted like the milk had gone bad or something. There was this weird biscotti-like taste to the nog. So I dumped in some bourbon… but that taste was still there. I dumped in even more bourbon and even more milk, but the horrible taste couldn’t be squelched. Mind you, the original recipe calls for 2 parts nog to 1 part milk OR liquor, and I was at about 4 parts milk AND bourbon to 1 part nog. It was like a party in my mouth and everybody had the trots.
For YOU people I went back and tried the filthy shit again before writing this post, and I was finally able to put my finger on what the taste was: licorice. It was like drinking eggnog through a straw made of black licorice. It’s absolutely repulsive, and I’m not sure what makes it taste that way, but when you can add so much booze and milk and the licorice flavor still comes through… well, I’d say we have a problem.
Then again, I also hate that shitty pre-liquored nog that you can buy, and I know lots of people who love it, so it might just be me in this case. Either way, I’ll never drink it again, and maybe it’ll save you about 11 bucks. And having to learn what it’s like to be hit in the face with a sack of warm diarrhea.
Until next year, thus ends the nog diaries. Like Sex in the City, but with less lactose intolerance.


Isn’t there a Trader Joe’s right there in GB, on the main drag? Parking kinda sucks but Trader Joe’s is worth it….
Thanks for taking another hit for the team, not to mention saving me eleven bucks.
What, in your opinion, is the very best nog?
Why did they trade-mark the ’simple’ in the title? How can you trademark just the word ‘ Simple’ without the ‘egg-nog’ bit? It’s not like they are going to be so famous for their egg-nog brand that people can say “hit me with a glass of that Simple”. Especially if it tastes yucky like you say it does.
ps Will be in the US of A as of Thursday!
Ew! Licorice is one of the nastiest tastes ever.
What can be said about Stirring’s eggnog that hasn’t already been said about getting hit in the face with a warm sack of diarrhea?
That reminds me, yes, the 1/10 Cloverland nog had expired by 1/11.
As we were wandering the aisles and gazing upon row after row of jarred peacock in truffle oil and ivory shavings, canned polar bear toes, and freeze-dried Irish babies
Irish babies don’t freeze well, they’re best when marinated in Bushmill’s. As it has been around since 1608, even Dr. Swift would probably agree with me.
You, my friend, are an IDIOT!
Your lovely bride says, “That had better be some good fucking eggnog.”, and you drink it instead of bringing it into the bedroom with you?
For shame! But, it does explain the whole metrosexuality…
And my mother’s not metro, she’s dead! OK, not really, but I doubt if she knows what metrosexualism is. I’ll ask her the next time I talk to her.
The bottle looks kinda neat, but not $11 worth of fucking neat. So sorry for your loss.
Shopping in Anne Arundel is like being subjected to the world’s longest Thanksgiving dinner with the in-laws. Makes me wanna curbstomp a cracker.
It is to you that I look for all things nog related. You have certainly saved this fair maiden from making a bad simple egg nog choice. Thank you, ACW, for once again making my nog life complete.
I found your site quite by accident but like it