This was actually my first nog purchase of the season. Mrs. ACW and I were idly traipsing around the store (actually, to be honest, we weren’t idly traipsing at all. Mrs. ACW has this set method of shopping, and it includes getting produce first, non-perishable items second, frozen food third, dairy fourth, and meats last. It’s just the opposite of idle, it’s OCD) when we came across the holiday food display set up on the endcap of the dairy aisle. I was trying to find Pumpkin Spice flavoring for Mrs. ACW (she really loves that stuff. Once, I saw her measure it out in 4 thin lines before snorting each one. For the next two days it was like kissing someone who had just eaten some pumpkin pie. She’s got a problem. Not like me and my nog though, we’re fine. I mean, I’m fine.) and by some chance, they not only had two kinds of pumpkin spice flavoring, but they also had eggnog flavoring!
I figured the eggnog flavoring would hold me over until the harder stuff real eggnog hit store shelves. I don’t really drink coffee though, so I was at an impasse.
We bought our crap (and shoplifted some candybars from the checkout aisle, because I have serious, serious problems) and when we got home I started brewing Mrs. ACW a pot of coffee. Once the coffee was ready I added two tablespoons of eggnog flavoring (per the directions) and gave the coffee to my lovely wife.
I think Mrs. ACW best summed up her thoughts in the first word of her critique. “Blech, this tastes awful!” I sipped the coffee, and it was like drinking warm, bitter, old eggnog that had been made in a toilet tank and strained through a canvas sack of old jock straps. I figured something must have been wrong with the flavoring, so I poured a little into a shot glass and took a sip. It tasted fine (kind of like soapy bathwater with eggnog in it, but that’s what all Coffemate tastes like), so I poured myself about half a shot of it and went for a larger taste. Still fine. Still soapy bathwater.
On our next trip to the store I bought a box of instant hot chocolate mix, and once I had a cup of that pulled together I poured in some of the eggnog flavoring. Now THAT tasted good. It was like the eggnog latte from Starbucks, except I didn’t feel so effete. (Seriously, the few times I am actually holding a take-out cup from a coffee shop, I just want to punch myself in the face. How do you people walk around with those things and feel normal? Look, we’re friends, right? Right. You look like a douche with that stupid cup. There. I said it.) Anyway, Mrs. ACW went on to bastardize what was a perfectly fine eggnog substitute by adding marshmallow fluff to all of her eggnog hot chocolates since then, making them some sort of nogchocomallow (marshnoglate? chocmalnog?) drink that was perfect for children striving for early onset diabetes. It’s like a punch in the pancreas.
So, in conclusion, I wouldn’t recommend eggnog flavoring for coffee, but it is good with hot chocolate. However, this all begs the question: if you’re going to pour eggnog flavoring into your drink, why be a sissy about it? Just add real eggnog instead. The thing to remember this holiday season is that eggnog can be legitimately used as a substitute for milk. And not just in recipes, but in cereal too.


